Posts

Examining "Appropriate" Children's Books, and the Problems They Present

               The article “How Book Banning Marginalizes Children” shows just how unwilling people are to teach children about prominent issues that, while challenging, are essential for their education. Ringel writes that the main problem with these works is “diverse content,” which is essentially anything featuring queer or multicultu ral characters and beliefs. While concerning , this prompted me to look into “appropriate works” and the hypocrisy that they demonstrate .   The National Health Institute defines childhood as 3-11 years old, so I looked at books in this age range using suggested reading lists on the Barnes & Noble website f or ages 3-5, 6- 8 , and 9 - 12 . The 3-5 year range has books like Phil Rosenthal’s Just Try It! , a story about trying new foods and Marcus Cutler’s I Do Not Eat Children , a bedtime story about monsters who are not actually evil. Books for this age range seem to revolve around these t...

Mullally and Ringel on Book Banning

    I found both of these articles to be very illuminating on the issue of book banning in America in the twenty-first century. To begin with Mullally's article and her assessment of the history of literary censorship in the West, I find her argument to be quite compelling. Mullally covers two aspects of censorship history that I think are important to consider in our modern day discussions. The first is the aspect of who has the authority to pass judgment on texts and create laws or statutes that result in their prohibition or destruction. Mullally points out throughout history that it is always sources of entrenched, systemic influence who can effect censorship in a widescale manner. She indicates sources of authority such as the British Crown and the Catholic Church who have enacted censorship laws throughout history, and she expertly traces a through-line demonstrating that the reason texts are censored by these large, powerful cultural institutions is because many of...